Regarding Zi Jian's rebute on my post.
What is happening now at the present does not represent what may happen in the future. In my examples, what is of concern is not of the current state the country is in but actually what the country may become. With the more and more people not caring about their vote or favouring their votes with illogical reasons, the problem of future government and decision not being the best arises.
Tuesday, July 8, 2008
Wen ti zai na li?
I think the root of whatever problem concerning democracy is not due to its nature, but its people. The same goes for communism, dictatorship, aristocracy or whatever system we humans believe in. As long as we have "thinking things" behind our governance, we are bound to have conflict and struggle, since humans werent born of the same mind, nor could possibly be.
But perhaps democracy has a slight edge over the rest regarding this problem, or so I believe, because it allows for debate, skepticism and contrast of ideas. It takes into perspective many points of view, something which tackles the problem of conflicting ideas.
I may "solve" conflict by making everyone agree with me through brute force and employing "thought police", but it is only going to show that I'm incapable of agreeing with everyone. I can't say that democracy necessarily brings agreement among everyone, but it sure is working towards it in a civilised manner that allows for even the smallest of people to make loud their voice. Thus it should be the total agreement of people that we should be trying to achieve, and not merely the form of government which is best.
But of course, as with all other parts of life, sacrifice is ultimately needed. If we want others to change to suit our liking, we must first make sure we are willing to change to suit them. This principle in life is key to achieving harmony among people.
But perhaps democracy has a slight edge over the rest regarding this problem, or so I believe, because it allows for debate, skepticism and contrast of ideas. It takes into perspective many points of view, something which tackles the problem of conflicting ideas.
I may "solve" conflict by making everyone agree with me through brute force and employing "thought police", but it is only going to show that I'm incapable of agreeing with everyone. I can't say that democracy necessarily brings agreement among everyone, but it sure is working towards it in a civilised manner that allows for even the smallest of people to make loud their voice. Thus it should be the total agreement of people that we should be trying to achieve, and not merely the form of government which is best.
But of course, as with all other parts of life, sacrifice is ultimately needed. If we want others to change to suit our liking, we must first make sure we are willing to change to suit them. This principle in life is key to achieving harmony among people.
Uh no...
Hey but look at the Swiss and us, we're both doing well! Uh I mean though the constant need to vote may cause the vote itself to lose value, it doesnt really pose a problem if people still make mature decisions and respect democracy as the privilege that it really is. We cannot say that just because people vote over and over again, they lose sight of important matters and neglect the importance of their vote. I believe that the people who turn up to vote, no matter how few, still believe in making the best use out of their vote.
Moreover, when it comes to voting for constitutional changes, the Swiss have a system where the vote of the majority of even the smallest province has the same power as a vote from a large city like Zurich. This balance is beautiful. It ensures that the major laws governing the country arent changed as easily, since the small provinces' are likely to be more conservative, whereas the large cities are more liberal.
And I'm not so sure whether Singapore is getting tired of the PAP. Though I personally have not been governed under another party or system of government, I believe it is clear that Singaporeans and the PAP are of one heart, or at least they only disagree to such a tiny extent that it doesnt show up in the newspapers. I think when people look outside and see a world that's in chaos because of inefficient forms of government, they would look inside and be grateful for the safe environment that they live in. Though we "comprain" a lot, we are still willing sacrifice some freedom for the sake of our country's safety.
Moreover, when it comes to voting for constitutional changes, the Swiss have a system where the vote of the majority of even the smallest province has the same power as a vote from a large city like Zurich. This balance is beautiful. It ensures that the major laws governing the country arent changed as easily, since the small provinces' are likely to be more conservative, whereas the large cities are more liberal.
And I'm not so sure whether Singapore is getting tired of the PAP. Though I personally have not been governed under another party or system of government, I believe it is clear that Singaporeans and the PAP are of one heart, or at least they only disagree to such a tiny extent that it doesnt show up in the newspapers. I think when people look outside and see a world that's in chaos because of inefficient forms of government, they would look inside and be grateful for the safe environment that they live in. Though we "comprain" a lot, we are still willing sacrifice some freedom for the sake of our country's safety.
Monday, July 7, 2008
Yeah XD_3
Thanks Ding Hao for your interesting info about Singapore and Switzerland.
About the case of Switzerland, I think it might be an exception. The Swiss govt doesn't promote the multi-parties policies, so total Democracy is their main ideology. Having just one party to rule over and over again, the people must get bored due to the repeated governing methods, and gradually lose interests in it.
That's why the multi-parties policies are important in a democratic society, alright.
About the case of Switzerland, I think it might be an exception. The Swiss govt doesn't promote the multi-parties policies, so total Democracy is their main ideology. Having just one party to rule over and over again, the people must get bored due to the repeated governing methods, and gradually lose interests in it.
That's why the multi-parties policies are important in a democratic society, alright.
Voting?
Democracy may allow us to vote but there is a big problem in this aspect. As we all know, voting is a very important part in deciding a country's future and the general population are normally happy when given the chance to vote and be part of this process.
However, we need to note that as time goes by, this "vote" that we swear by may lose in value and many may not value their vote as much as before. There are two cases in which this happens.
First is the case of Singapore. We are a democratic country that chooses our parties mainly by voting. Throughout the times, we can see that we mainly made the right choice and the country is being governed well by the ruling party namely the PAP. However the PAP is also having a sort of complete dominance in the country for such a long time and this may not be favourable. For one, the people may start to get bored with the ruling party and thus decide that they want a more "exciting" form of governance, this may thus lead them to vote for the opposition. Whether this decision of voting for the opposition is right or wrong, its impossible to tell right now. But the very fact that this mindset is present in many people, we can see that the people are definitly starting to value their vote less and less.
Next is the case further away from home, Switzerland. The swiss governing system is different from singapore's which is a represantative democracy. The swiss is governed by a system of complete democracy. This form of democracy requires the voting by the swiss on almost all major matters. This is good such that the swiss population has a say in almost every matter of the country, however this also cause the population to value their votes to a very small extent due to the complete abundance of the chances to vote. As statistics tell, Switzerland has only an average voter turnout of 54% for 8 national lower house elections from 1960 to 1995. From this we can see that if given to much chance to vote, when the really important matters, such as elections, arrives, the population would not value and treasure their vote.
However, we need to note that as time goes by, this "vote" that we swear by may lose in value and many may not value their vote as much as before. There are two cases in which this happens.
First is the case of Singapore. We are a democratic country that chooses our parties mainly by voting. Throughout the times, we can see that we mainly made the right choice and the country is being governed well by the ruling party namely the PAP. However the PAP is also having a sort of complete dominance in the country for such a long time and this may not be favourable. For one, the people may start to get bored with the ruling party and thus decide that they want a more "exciting" form of governance, this may thus lead them to vote for the opposition. Whether this decision of voting for the opposition is right or wrong, its impossible to tell right now. But the very fact that this mindset is present in many people, we can see that the people are definitly starting to value their vote less and less.
Next is the case further away from home, Switzerland. The swiss governing system is different from singapore's which is a represantative democracy. The swiss is governed by a system of complete democracy. This form of democracy requires the voting by the swiss on almost all major matters. This is good such that the swiss population has a say in almost every matter of the country, however this also cause the population to value their votes to a very small extent due to the complete abundance of the chances to vote. As statistics tell, Switzerland has only an average voter turnout of 54% for 8 national lower house elections from 1960 to 1995. From this we can see that if given to much chance to vote, when the really important matters, such as elections, arrives, the population would not value and treasure their vote.
3rd POV
But although there may be foul play in the election process, we can't deny that the voting system in Democracy is really well-built. The policy of making each person vote once really ensures that every man has to take responsibility for the whole nation,right?
Looking back at Autocracy, it's surely not unstable. The people is, like, blindfolded, leaving their entire welfare to the Dictator. Have to admit that Autocracy is literally an one-man show; hence dictatorial societies will soon crumble.
So Democracy, I think, will bring about stability to the society, despite the minuses.
Looking back at Autocracy, it's surely not unstable. The people is, like, blindfolded, leaving their entire welfare to the Dictator. Have to admit that Autocracy is literally an one-man show; hence dictatorial societies will soon crumble.
So Democracy, I think, will bring about stability to the society, despite the minuses.
Sunday, July 6, 2008
Yeah XD_2
Come to think of it, about the multi-parties thing, I am not really so sure that this would work out. Like in the USA, although the paties seem to play it all fair and square, I still think there exists foul play, cuz the party, which all of us thought would be the winner, eventually lost the election, since the opposite party didn't hesitate to throw out money to buy votes.
The majority may not usually be wise. They have a tendency to favor candidates whose policies consume less of their money.
So yeah, I agree with Nich :P. Democracy is only good in specific situations. We can not abuse it too much like what many leaders are doing to their nations.
The majority may not usually be wise. They have a tendency to favor candidates whose policies consume less of their money.
So yeah, I agree with Nich :P. Democracy is only good in specific situations. We can not abuse it too much like what many leaders are doing to their nations.
I think we've reached an agreement :D
I agree with you wholeheartedly.
This is why Bush administration fails. They think that their solution is the creme of the creme and refuse to admit that it is just a whole load of bull.
I think we can safely agree that democracy is beneficial to the society situationally. :D
I hope zi and dinghao post soon =.=
This is why Bush administration fails. They think that their solution is the creme of the creme and refuse to admit that it is just a whole load of bull.
I think we can safely agree that democracy is beneficial to the society situationally. :D
I hope zi and dinghao post soon =.=
Yeah XD
Yeah, because Democracy is just a form of Society; we can not mistake it as something that can dispose of all bad deeds and make people have the same opinions. It has its flaws too.
I think the US is kind of a failure now, thanks to Mr.Bush.
Anyway, let's not talk about it now. Democracy must be more than this.
I am still very fond of Democracy. You see how it benefitted Africa? It helped cease the long-lasting conflicts and bring stability to the country, making it economically firmer.
South Africa is now a very potential candidate to become a key member in the UNSC (United Nations Security Council).
I think the US is kind of a failure now, thanks to Mr.Bush.
Anyway, let's not talk about it now. Democracy must be more than this.
I am still very fond of Democracy. You see how it benefitted Africa? It helped cease the long-lasting conflicts and bring stability to the country, making it economically firmer.
South Africa is now a very potential candidate to become a key member in the UNSC (United Nations Security Council).
But democracy is really overrated in my humble opinion.
Take the case of Iraq under the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein, the US government thinks that all these extremist stuff started cause of dictatorship and proposed that democracy be implemented. My views are similar to the article writer, the US sure are naive and superficial.
Yes, democracy does solve problems, but yet, there would still be unhappy citizens around (this is inevitable for any case anyway) when their policy loses by a small margin. So, democracy can only be useful until this extent.
Edit: Ok, just read Hai's post. Yea, so we both agree that democracy can only do that much :D
Take the case of Iraq under the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein, the US government thinks that all these extremist stuff started cause of dictatorship and proposed that democracy be implemented. My views are similar to the article writer, the US sure are naive and superficial.
Yes, democracy does solve problems, but yet, there would still be unhappy citizens around (this is inevitable for any case anyway) when their policy loses by a small margin. So, democracy can only be useful until this extent.
Edit: Ok, just read Hai's post. Yea, so we both agree that democracy can only do that much :D
MPP(Multi-Parties Policy).
What I like most in Democracy is the multi-parties policy. People got to choose which ideological party they want, and the one which has more votes will govern the country for a brief period.
That is fair, I think, for many people.
That is fair, I think, for many people.
Re...but...
Hehe, sorry Nich for spamming so much.
I'd like to have a word here. Although Democracy does seem tyrant that way, it can't be helped. At least it can satisfy the most people, right?
Let's see it this way: Democracy in fact doesn't throw the minority's idea out of consideration. I've read sources on this and there is an important factor that prevents the violation of the rights of the minority; it's Political Tolerance. Democracy will be destroyed if the Majority refuse the rights and opinions of their opposition.
Well, that's just my idea, I guess...
I'd like to have a word here. Although Democracy does seem tyrant that way, it can't be helped. At least it can satisfy the most people, right?
Let's see it this way: Democracy in fact doesn't throw the minority's idea out of consideration. I've read sources on this and there is an important factor that prevents the violation of the rights of the minority; it's Political Tolerance. Democracy will be destroyed if the Majority refuse the rights and opinions of their opposition.
Well, that's just my idea, I guess...
Saturday, July 5, 2008
2nd POV
In my opinion, democracy is highly overrated. Let's say, if the majority consists of a little over 50%, like 51% to the "minority" of 49%, then the law would or would not be implemented due to "majority" vote. I feel this does not exactly appease all the citizens of that country as the numbers of supporters are very close, therefore, a huge number of people would be disappointed.
I feel that a democratic government should do more than that. They should go an extra mile. Compromising both ideas so that equilibrium is reached rather than throwing the "minority" idea out to the sea. They should really hear the citizen's opinions on things and make the decision. :D
And last words to hai. YOU'RE A SPAMMER =.=
I feel that a democratic government should do more than that. They should go an extra mile. Compromising both ideas so that equilibrium is reached rather than throwing the "minority" idea out to the sea. They should really hear the citizen's opinions on things and make the decision. :D
And last words to hai. YOU'RE A SPAMMER =.=
Sidetrack info
Okay, just to let you know some more on Democracy, I can post some more.
Democary is mainly constituted from consensus, tolerance, intellectual/political choice and peace, a.k.a harmony or social stability-up to you...
Democary is mainly constituted from consensus, tolerance, intellectual/political choice and peace, a.k.a harmony or social stability-up to you...
Why Consensus?
See how many Autocratic societies fail? Because of the usual absence of Consensus. Rulers impose laws on citizens unreasonably, then what happens? The people will gradually foster unrest and a sense of riots.
In the case of Democracy, people can choose what laws and regulations to enforce, and even who will govern them. I think it's kinda double-sided: the people and the government rule each other; from there, we can prevent social controversies over political decrees, hence social destabilization.
I'm kind of supporting Democracy here. Two thumbs up!
Anyone out there wants to protest, be my guest!
In the case of Democracy, people can choose what laws and regulations to enforce, and even who will govern them. I think it's kinda double-sided: the people and the government rule each other; from there, we can prevent social controversies over political decrees, hence social destabilization.
I'm kind of supporting Democracy here. Two thumbs up!
Anyone out there wants to protest, be my guest!
1st POV
Not sure if you guys approve this or not, but I just post here k?
Okay… Democracy in theory does bring better things to the societies, and help foster harmony and stability… It’s all thanks to its most important factor: Consensus! Why? Consensus is literally the agreement among people into a decision, policies or somethin’. It helps somehow soothe quarrels over what are to be executed, and to be prevented, since people got to choose their own path and governing methods.
Anyone wants to rebut, be my guest.
Okay… Democracy in theory does bring better things to the societies, and help foster harmony and stability… It’s all thanks to its most important factor: Consensus! Why? Consensus is literally the agreement among people into a decision, policies or somethin’. It helps somehow soothe quarrels over what are to be executed, and to be prevented, since people got to choose their own path and governing methods.
Anyone wants to rebut, be my guest.
Wazzzzup!!!
New Topic!!!! Need Ultra Special Attention!!!
To all blox’s members!
Guys, today I suddenly got it all politics!! So I want to create a topic on politics, alright?
This week’s issue will be on social ideologies. Thinking about them, are you having the same thoughts as me? Yeah, I am going to discuss about “Democracy vs. Dictatorship ‘n Others”, which has been a hot topic among babblers like us!
The ancient Asia that we are living in is not really ancient anymore; instead, it’s aiming for enormous modernization. Many countries have turned democratic, and Democracy has been the key word in arguments, and the tip-of-the-tongue word that people are upholding.
Apparently, I'm pretty curious about this; what better things Democracy brings than other ideologies like Dictatorship? Anyone got answer pls post right below this string. Hopefully we will have an interesting time brooding over and over this matter and gain so much more knowledge on what has become the keyword of this globalization era!
To all blox’s members!
Guys, today I suddenly got it all politics!! So I want to create a topic on politics, alright?
This week’s issue will be on social ideologies. Thinking about them, are you having the same thoughts as me? Yeah, I am going to discuss about “Democracy vs. Dictatorship ‘n Others”, which has been a hot topic among babblers like us!
The ancient Asia that we are living in is not really ancient anymore; instead, it’s aiming for enormous modernization. Many countries have turned democratic, and Democracy has been the key word in arguments, and the tip-of-the-tongue word that people are upholding.
Apparently, I'm pretty curious about this; what better things Democracy brings than other ideologies like Dictatorship? Anyone got answer pls post right below this string. Hopefully we will have an interesting time brooding over and over this matter and gain so much more knowledge on what has become the keyword of this globalization era!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)